I'm tstaff in question, My thoughts on this after looking back. -
Even though this player was very clearly a traitor, you still had no right to kos him. meaning since he reported you, and kept the report. you got a slay for killing him without a valid kos.
You kos'd him for "Deductive Reasoning" and sound/location
It was nothing personal, it was a slay because you did not have a valid reason to kos.
Personally, i would like to see deductive reasoning become a part of moat's kos rules some day. But as it stands, they arent.
you said the same thing in pm's 10 times disregarding my follow up response each time and responding with the same thing you already said. So i told you to stop pming me the same thing over and over as it's obviously going nowhere after 5 minutes of conversation, and the slay long gone. and told you to either a) make a staff complaint if you felt i handled the situation poorly, or b) pm a higher up, because they will tell you the same thing.
This situation is still KOS off of sound/location, regardless of the role the person is.
Yes, It is kosable. If you see it, not hear it.